Is the Anglican Church selling out Tasmania?

"The Anglican Church in Tasmania is proposing to sell over 120 properties to fund its projected obligations to provide redress for survivors of child sexual abuse. 

This sacrifice expresses the church’s desire to provide restorative justice, recognition and support to survivors for the wrongs they have experienced by past leaders of the church.

So, who is responsible for paying for these wrongs? As the current members of the church didn’t perpetrate the wrongs, one might think they should not have to pay.But the church should pay, because taking collective responsibility for past wrongs is not only right it is profound and powerful."

Congregations throughout Tasmania are reeling. Many congregations and communities are desperately searching for ways to have their churches removed from the list or buy out to set up as community churches and chapels. 

In a nut shell, the Dioceses has decided to sell off half of the Church's properties! Predominantly in small rural areas and of buildings of historical significance. Claiming those earmarked are 'unsustainable' in the long term. Although a cynical mind might add that these will also be the easiest to sell and at higher value than later built structures. Forgetting of course that congregations have waxed and waned since the 1950's. Yes things are currently in a period of decline, but that may change. People often return to something familiar and safe when times become difficult. 

There have been claims that a building is just a building, but I'd beg to differ. These churches have historically been the epicentre of communities, generation upon generation. If the church is failing to fill the pews - then perhaps it is a failing of the church(s) to remain current and relevant. If religion is no longer relevant in today's society why then the phenomenon of the mega-church or the growing success of Riverlink in the Tamar Valley. 

These examples make it clear that there is still a need and willingness to connect to faith. Which means the failing is with us - as a church. 

The only real way to keep these assets within the Anglican family, is to fill those pews. Night / evening services for those unable to be there on Sunday's due to family, sport, work or other commitments. Run High Anglican Services AND more 'middle of the road' services out of the same church. 'All creatures great and small' services for those who's families include the furred and feathered. Younger clergy - and perhaps more 'Gosford Anglican' style 'rebels'. 'Secular' services open to those families and friends who belong to other denominations and even atheists. 

For the Anglican Church to survive, grow and survive - it is not enough to have a structure. The Anglican Church MUST reengage with community, from within the community itself. It is little wonder that churches / congregations such as St. Andrews at Evandale are struggling to survive - in fact this probably one won't - which is utterly mind boggling for a busy and growing town, with an enormous weekend market and tourist destination, but churches like this one, don't stand a chance when the local Reverend is forced to divide time and energy across multiple churches in multiple towns, rather than 'of the town, in the town'.


For those of us wishing to voice our displeasure:

Attention: The Right Revd Dr Richard Condie
Bishop of Tasmania
Anglican Diocese of Tasmania
Level 1, 125 Macquarie Street
Hobart TAS 7000

GPO Box 748
Hobart TAS 7001 

Phone: 03 6220 2020
Email: registry@anglicantas.org.au

Last thing, if your community is in the firing line - I'd love to hear from you.




The God Argument.

 Recently I've been reading A. C Grayling's 'The God Argument: The Case Against Religion and For Humanism'. 

Whilst it's an intriguing argument and well written, it is a little irritating. Admittedly I'm only halfway through, but the supposition that religion and humanism cannot co-exist is rubbish. As is the assumption that the Bible, when not taken literally means that one must be an 'apologist'. At this rate might be needing an elephant size pooper-scooper.

However, pages 66 and 67 "...The standard arguments for the existence of God..." have me thinking. That's thinking - not leaping to conclusions and I'm sure these will crop up in some future blogs. So here they are as listed within the text:

Telological Argument.  The argument for design ('intelligent design' falls in here; puppy-poo-bag anyone? )
Ontological Argument. God exists by definition. 
Cosmology Argument. Attempts an empirical basis for the existence of God. "...the world cannot be it's own entity..." 
Moral Argument. There can not be morality unless there is a God. Yep, the favorite argument of fundamentalists. This is the one used to justify their zealot ideology, bigotry, homophobia, misogyny and even in some cases white supremacy. These people are not Christians, but rather use it to justify their lack of humanity, compassion and control issues.

So whilst I'm still mulling over these points, I'd like to hear read your thoughts on each of these points. Feel free to DM them to me via twitter @VacuousNess





Safe Schools and Gender Fluidity

Safe Schools and Gender Fluidity: Conservative Christian Hype v’s Reality.

In 1997 Tasmania became the last Australian state to decriminalize consensual homosexual acts between adult men. There was nothing remarkable about this, except the length of time it had taken. The push toward gay law reform in Tasmania, commencing, in the 1970’s.

What this meant and what I witnessed amongst my own teenage peer group, was not only uncomfortable but also painful to watch.
There are two things, which resonate the loudest, to this day:
1.     During the height of the AIDS crisis, information and education was not provided to Tasmanian students, or was restricted to HSC (now TCE) students only. Despite the fact that HIV was no longer a ‘gay disease’ but was now virulent amongst the heterosexual community. Thus placing all sexually active Tasmanian teens at risk.
2.     Almost all of my LGBT friends did not ‘come out’ until they were old enough to leave Tasmania. Many forming ‘camouflage relationships with sympathetic friends of the opposite gender.

Imagine for one moment living and growing up in this environment. Unable to be open and truthful about whom, you are. Then consider how this would affect your own mental health.

Luckily, nationally, this is no longer the case. What I see now amongst the peer groups my teenage niece and nephews is quite the opposite. They are able to be open, honest and comfortable with themselves, their sexuality and relationships – whatever that might be and to the greater extent, their peer groups are completely accepting.

Unfortunately, in Australia we are now witnessing a rise from the fundamentalist Christian Conservative, politicians, press, Australian Christian Lobby (ACL) and shock jocks such as cranky pants Latham. Lyle Shelton is becoming incredibly vocal, particularly when it comes to the Safe Schools Program*.

The tactics these individuals and groups employ are nothing short of outright lies and blatant shock tactic misinformation. They’ve included untruths such as One Nation claiming primary school childrenare being taught masturbation.

"...Aaaannnnd then Mrs Mentula said, Swallow don't Spit and always wear your raincoat when it's raining!"
So what is the truth?
In a nutshell Safe Schools began in Victorian Govt Schools in 2010, thanks to the Safe Schools Coalition. It has since become a national program. 
  • Safe Schools is a voluntary program, not a curriculum (absolutely not compulsory). 
  • Safe Schools is run at the discretion of principals, teachers and the school community, with schools able to use as little or as much of the resources as they choose.
  • The program was devised and originally available to Govt secondary schools, however, it is now accessible to non-Govt and primary schools. 
  • Safe Schools DO NOT teach gender fluidity. 


What is Safe Schools is:
A program, which assists schools to create and foster a supportive, inclusive and safe environment for LGBT students. The aim is to tackle bullying and harassment and prevent self harm and suicide.


Why?
The rate of self harm and suicide is sixtimes higher in same sex youth, than within their heterosexual peers, with the first suicide attempt at around 16years of age. These youngsters aren’t self harming and attempting suicide because the are LGBT, but because they are being bullied, harassed, beaten up, threatened etc. within their own schools and no child learns or reaches their full potential in such environments.

Those who publically sprook false information and outright lies about the Safe Schools program, particularly within the public domain, do so with only one agenda and that is to force their brand of ultra conservative ideology onto a secular Australia. In so doing they are using the very mechanisms Safe Schools aims to remove from Australian schools.

When they attack programs such as SafeSchools, they are using the health and well being of Australian youth to forward their cause. This is child abuse and this is before we even consider the impact of gay conversion therapy, a practice must become illegal in every state and territory.

Whilst these groups represent less than 1% of Australian Christians, let us not forget or turn a blind eye to what is occurring in the USA. Particularly whilst the Australian Tax Office continues to consider groups such as the ACL to be ‘Religious Organizations’ – they are not, they are political lobby groups and must be taxed and held accountable accordingly. They should never be allowed to use Australia’s younger generations to be used as cannon fodder in their intolerant zealot cause. 

To those conservatives wishing to use religion as an excuse for all this, I say. For decades secular Australia had to tolerate Christian studies in Govt schools and even quite recently (then) Prime Minister Tony Abbott, placed Chaplains in schools; instead of mental health professionals. So to these people and organisations, my answer is simply; if you don't like programs such as Safe Schools, simply remove your offspring, home educate, or find schools which do not use such programs and do not force your fundamentalist Christian views on the other 99% of Christians you don't represent nor secular Australian society. 




*Same Sex Marriage (and homosexuality) we will discuss another day. 
Image: original drawing by VacuousNess

Anzac Day and the Yassmin Abdel-Magied controversy

 “Listen, don't mention the war! I mentioned it once, but I think I got away with it…”

 
It’s a little over one year since, Yassmin Abdel-Magied’s controversial social media post sparked one of the ugliest social media back lashes I’ve ever seen, by which time she had already apologised and deleted the post.

What followed was nothing short of a national disgrace an aggressive and sustained media bombardment against one woman; and for what, a simple comment “Lest we forget (Manus)”. Ironically the loudest and most disproportionally aggressively of those vilifying Yassmin, were those repeatedly claiming that ‘free speech’ in Australia is under threat (whilst using media and social media to do so).

The incident, exposed the ugly truth about modern day Australia; laying bare a nation low on empathy, sympathy, tolerance and big on racial, religious and social hatred. The nation showed itself to be intolerant of asylum seekers, individuals on welfare and all the weakest and powerless in society - and then the mainstream media added their two bob’s worth.

The hysteria, which followed Yassmin’s Facebook post, cannot be separated from xenophobia, racism and misogyny. If Australians are to be truly honest with themselves then they must acknowledge that Anzac Day has been a source of controversy and protest for a very long time. Even in the 1960’s being used as an opportunity to protest the Vietnam War.

Yassmin did not criticise Australian Soldiers and she did not comment on the politics of war. Her post simply and succinctly asked us to remember, not only lives lost in previous wars, but also the lives of those currently in harms way; fighting in, living in and fleeing conflict zones. Instead she was faced with a lynch mob of conservative politicians and press, most of who claim to be ‘Christians’. Yet their conduct in this was anything but!

In this simple act one brown Muslim woman showed more Christian understanding of the suffering of her fellow (hu)man than all those attacking her combined.

One hopes that Yassmin and those like her will continue to maintain the courage and humanity she displayed and continues to display.

So tomorrow on Anzac day, one hopes all Australians of conscience will remember not only those Anzacs past and present, but also those: fighting, living, fleeing and dying in current conflicts.

This in no way detracts from the Anzac legend and sacrifice, rather acknowledges their sacrifice and reminds us how much Australian and New Zealand troops still contribute to the nation and the world.

Lest we forget.






Image: original drawing by VacuousNess

Intolerance, Bigotry and Religious Freedom

What are religious texts really? Well, essentially they are nothing more than guidebooks for life, of which religious leaders have always retained absolute control of the text in so doing making, religious leaders the influential, powerful force providing direction. However, what an individual does with that information is another matter. 

Religion must always teach kindness, respect and tolerance; it must never condone greed, violence and war. Those of faith should always be seeking common features amongst religions (and groups within their own faith), common features which, bring them together rather than pushing them apart.

Unfortunately in the current global political climate, it appears bigotry and intolerance are increasing and appears to making conservative, fundamentalist and radical Christians more vocal in their bigotry.

Bigotry pushes for the freedom to deny others the identical rights of everyone else – and be thanked, free of the consequences their actions bring.

In this environment, Progressives have a moral obligation and duty to stand up to this, to clearly and irrevocably state, ‘this is not OK’.

In refusing to accept their bigotry we are not rescinding their rights to be the obnoxious petty myopic minded bigot wish to be – such individuals are still free to wallow in their bigotry, but they cannot and should never be permitted to avoid the consequences as their bigotry forces their beliefs onto others, without the permission of those others. Therefore bigots do not have the right to insulate themselves from the consequences of their actions, prejudices etc.

Religion must always provide benevolent guidance and influence. Obviously all religions attempt to lead their followers down a path of care and respect for others* which means religious leaders must bear the responsibility of direction. It is their responsibility to teach kindness, tolerance and respect. To spread a message of peace, not condone: bigotry, violence, greed or war. Discrimination is not genetic; it is, learned and fostered.

Is it ever okay to be intolerant? Yes it is.

It is okay to be intolerant of:
  • ·      Politics which attempt to create and ensure a climate safe for bigotry to flourish and disguise it as ‘respectability’.
  • ·      Legislation, which limits access to basic human rights, due to an individual’s: gender, race, sexual orientation, religion, gender expression etc. Or any legal system which is unbalanced (against) these groups:
  • ·      Mechanisms and environments, which protect those who bully LGBTQI youngsters under the façade of ‘protecting religious freedom’.
  • ·      The marginalisation of other religions or denominations.
  • ·      Killing civilians, just because they have the misfortune to live in a nation, our politicians don’t like.
  • ·      The politics of fear, which keeps refugees from finding a home amongst us and views such migrants as leeches, terrorists etc. rather than assets to nation and economy.
  • ·      Rape culture.
  • ·      Any system, which favors the wealthy over the poor.
  • ·      Those damaging the environment, by denying human responsibility for it / impact on it.

Bigotry is a choice and if it is your choice – fine, but you also have to live with and take responsibility for the consequences. Also don’t expect the rest of us to standby and not speak out. 

Particularly whilst the Australian Govt conducts the 'Religious Freedom Review'. One can only hope the voice of both Australian Secular Society, Moderate / Progressive Christians, The Australian Constitution and common sense prevail.  

Religion has no place in politics and bigotry has no place in Christianity (any religion or puplic policy).   

Last but no least, please remember, fundamentalism of any flavor is dangerous - it is not religion specific.


*I loath the word 'righteousness' as it always seems to me those using it, are often using it in an attempt to justify some crappy or nasty conduct.

What is a progressive Christian?


The answer may surprise many Atheists.

Progressive ( aka moderate) simply don’t believe the dogma. For the progressive dogma, fundamentalism, conservative (call it what you will) flavored Christianity obstructs: common sense, inclusion, kindness, science – and even in some circumstances, basic human rights.

We are not apologists. Unlike conservatives, we do not believe that the Bible is the true authoritative expression of God’s will, as in reality the Bible is the product of human beings with their own point of view and agendas. From a feminist point of view, it may also be argued that those human beings created a work of Patriarchy, when there is evidence to suggest women played a fundamental part in the early Christian Church (something to revisit in a future blog).

In a nut shell:
  • Kindness is religion and religion is kindness.
  • Faith not dogma.
  • Deeds not creeds.
  • Jesus is a true myth.
  • The Bible should be taken seriously not literally.
  • Questions matter more than answers.
  • Use your brain, be unapologetic (in faith).
  • God evolves, as does faith.
  • It is good to understand other faiths.
  • There is beauty in the myth and poetry of the Bible.
  • Peace and justice amongst all people.
  • Protect and save the Earth (environment).
  • Strive for a society, which is inclusive of all: regardless of nationality, religion, race, gender, sexual orientation and gender identity, class and / or ability.

This doesn’t quite cover everything, but it is a quick overview.

One last thing; don’t get sucked into the torture of the apologist trap, that s*!* will send you insane and it’s wasted energy.


Australian Agriculture & Potential impact of Trumpian politics.

Australian Agriculture & Potential impact of Trump politics.  It's been a while, but it's time to start blogging again. If only ...